The past two years this has gotten harder, though, as my oldest gets smarter and her mind gets more mechanical. She has so many questions, trying to make sense of things, and has really put my quick-thinking skills to the test. Why not just tell her the truth and keep her in on the secret, you ask? Because, given her personality, she will most definitely ruin it for her little brother and sister.
One of the steps I took this year was to hide all of the presents in the trunk of my car in the weeks leading up to Christmas. In addition to our gifts from each other, each of the kids gets a gift from "Santa." Since my eldest is very aware of the wrapping paper we have at home, I concocted a back story for Santa's presents.
After the kids went to bed on Christmas Eve, I wrapped up the presents from "Santa" with a special roll I bought for his gifts. There was still plenty of paper left on the roll, and I was worried that if I pulled it out again next year, she would notice. So, I propped the leftover roll against the fireplace and left a note from Santa on a scroll from the wrapping paper:
"Dear Alicia, Emma and Benjamin,
Thank your for the cookies and milk. They were very good. As you know, each family's presents get wrapped in a different paper. I had leftovers from your family, and it was too heavy for your Dad's stocking, so I left it against the fireplace.
Love, Santa.
P.S. You were very good this year."
Later, my daughter was very happy with Santa's honesty and showed the letter to everyone in the family.

